top of page

An Oscar Winner, a $160 Prescription and No Insurance: What to Do at the Counter

26 minutes ago
3 min read
Cover graphic reading An Oscar. A $160 prescription. No insurance., with a handwritten $160 note and a gold star on a wooden counter under a lamp

By Forest Park Pharmacy


Hilary Swank won an Oscar for Boys Don't Cry. She found out she had no health insurance at a pharmacy counter.


She told the story in October 2016 on Chelsea, Chelsea Handler's Netflix talk show. Page Six printed it this way:


"When I did 'Boys Don't Cry,' I was 24 years old. I made $3,000. In order to have health insurance, you have to make $5,000, so I didn't even know that I didn't have health insurance until I went and tried to get a prescription filled. They said, 'That's $160.' ... I had an Academy Award [and] no health insurance."

TIME and TheWrap covered the same interview. TheWrap's headline used her line: "I had an Academy Award, no health insurance."


We don't know what the prescription was, and it doesn't matter. What matters is where she found out. Not in a letter. At the register.


Why I'm telling it now


A lot of people find out about a gap in coverage the same way. A job changes, a plan lapses, a card stops working, and the first sign is a price at the counter.


Open enrollment for 2027 marketplace plans started Nov. 1 in most states. KFF reports that benchmark silver premiums are going up 13% on average for 2027, after rising 26% from 2025 to 2026. Some people will switch plans, some will be between plans, and some will end up paying cash for a while.


This isn't advice to skip insurance. It's a plan for the moment you're standing at the counter without it.


Your checklist for paying cash at the counter


  1. Ask for the cash price before you pay. Say it out loud: "What's the cash price for this?" Don't assume the first number is the only number.

  2. Compare pharmacies. Call another pharmacy or two with the drug name, strength and quantity. Prices for the same prescription can be very different.

  3. Check a posted price list. Some pharmacies post their cash prices online. If a price is posted, you can check it before you leave home.

  4. Ask about a generic. If your prescription is a brand name, ask whether there's a generic version and what it costs.

  5. Ask for a transfer. If another pharmacy has a better price, they can usually transfer your prescription for you.


What a cash price can look like


Cash prices can be much lower than people expect. Here are two from our own price table, compared with what Medicare paid per prescription in 2025:


Medicine

Medicare paid per prescription (2025)

Our cash price

Ursodiol

$144.74

$30

Icosapent

$222.70

$60


Why the gap? A lot of it is the middlemen between the patient and the pharmacy. We wrote about how that works in Spread pricing: how your PBM keeps the difference.


Questions people ask


What was Hilary Swank's prescription for? She didn't say in the interview, and we won't guess.


Should I drop my insurance and pay cash? That's your call, and I'm not telling you either way. This post is about what to do when you don't have coverage at the counter, or when a cash price beats your copay. Look at both numbers.


Can I ask for a cash price even if I have insurance? Yes. Ask for both numbers and pay the lower one where your plan allows it.


Why We Can Beat Their Price


We fired insurance at Forest Park Pharmacy. No claims, no middlemen taking a cut, and no plan rules deciding what you pay. We post a cash price for each medicine, and that's what you pay.


I run this pharmacy so nobody finds out the price at the register. You can see it before you fill.


Sources



From Our Shelf


If you or a parent is on a prescription for the long haul: Script Restore, $35.10, a daily supplement made for people taking long-term prescriptions. Browse more on our shop page.


Script Restore
Buy Now

Head to forestparkpharmacy.com to look at our price checker and transfer today to save. See ya.


 
 
bottom of page